Summary

A survey of links from UK Universities and Colleges institutional home pages to remote services was carried out. Very few institutions provided links to JISC services from their institutional home page. A number of institutions, although this relatively few, provided links to computer organisations (most notably Netscape and Microsoft) and to information about the region.

Background

On the evening of Friday, 24th October 1997 the WebWatch project, based at UKOLN, ran a robot which retrieved HTML elements from institutional home pages of UK University and Colleges, as defined by the HESA list [1]. The robot successfully accessed 158 resources.

A report on the subsequent analysis is to be published in Ariadne [2]. This report gives a summary of links to JISC services. In order to give some context to hypertext linking profiles from institutional home pages, it also summarises links to other services and commercial organisations.

Analysis of Links

JISC Services

Table 1 shows the institutional home pages which contain links to JISC services, as defined in the list of JISC services [3]. The data was searched for the JISC service name, except where indicated in brackets.

Table 1 - Links To JISC Services From Institutional Home Pages
Service and Nos. of Links Linked from
NISS - 2 links http://www.anglia.ac.uk/ "Anglia Polytechnic University"
http://www.marjon.ac.uk/ "University College of St Mark & St John"
BIDS - 1 link http://www.uwcm.ac.uk/ "University of Wales College of Medicine" [http and telnet links]
AHDS - 1 link http://www.kcl.ac.uk/ "King's College London"
UKOLN - 1 link http://www.aber.ac.uk/ "University of Wales Aberystwyth" [out of date link to Gopher server]
UKERNA - 1 link http://sun1.haac.ac.uk/ "Harper Adams Agricultural College"
JA (http://www.ja.net/) - 1 link http://www.sghms.ac.uk/ " St. George's Hospital Medical School"
AGOCG - 0 links
BUBL - 0 links
BUFVC - 0 links
CHEST - 0 links
COPAC - 0 links
Data Archive - 0 links
(http://dawww.essex.ac.uk/)
EDINA - 0 links
HENSA - 0 links
Mailbase - 0 links
MIDAS - 0 links
SOSIG - 0 links
JISC - 0 links

Links to Information Provided by JISC Services

There were 4 links to the JANET AUP document available at http://www.ja.net/documents/use.html from the following institutional home pages:

Other Related Services

Table 2 - Links To Other Academic Services and Projects From Institutional Home Pages
Service and Nos. of Links Linked from
OMNI - 1 link http://www.uwcm.ac.uk/
"University of Wales College of Medicine"
Edulib (http://www.hull.ac.uk/Hull/CTLS_Web/edulib/edulib.html)
- 1 link
http://www.chihe.ac.uk/
"Chichester Institute of Higher Education"

There were 2 links to the Dearing Report (http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/ncihe/) from:

Note that 6 other institutions had links on their home page to internal information about the Dearing report.

Links to Other Organisations

The following tables show links to commercial companies and non-profit-making organisations from institutional home pages.

Table 3 - Links To Commercial and Non-Commercial Software and Hardware Organisations From Institutional Home Pages
Service and Nos. of Links Linked from Comment
Netscape - 7 links http://www.bathhe.ac.uk/
"Bath Spa University College"
Help page on browser policy
http://www.bretton.ac.uk/
"University College Bretton Hall"
Contains Netscape 2.0 icon (also has Internet Explorer icon)
http://www.uce.ac.uk/
"University of Central England"
A FRAMEd site. The page for non-frames capable browser suggests downloading Netscape.
http://www.luton.ac.uk/
"University of Luton"
Contains Netscape Communicator icon best "Best Viewed" commentary (also has Internet Explorer icon)
http://www.port.ac.uk/
"University of Portsmouth"
A FRAMEd site. The page for non-frames capable browser suggests downloading Netscape.
http://www.ucrysj.ac.uk/
"University College of Ripon and York St John"
Contains Netscape icon best "This site designed for" commentary
http://www.sghms.ac.uk/
"St. George's Hospital Medical School"
Contains Netscape Communicator icon
Microsoft - 5 links http://www.bretton.ac.uk/
"University College Bretton Hall"
Contains Microsft Internet Explorer icon (Also has Netscape icon)
http://www.uce.ac.uk/
"University of Central England"
A FRAMEd site. The page for non-frames capable browser suggests downloading Internet Explorer.
http://www.luton.ac.uk/
"University of Luton"
Contains Internet Explorer icon best "Best Viewed" commentary (also has Netscape Communicator icon)
http://www.norcol.ac.uk/
"Northern College, Scotland"
A FRAMEd site. Contains Internet Explorer icon with "Best experienced" commentary.
http://www.tvu.ac.uk/
"Thames Valley University"
Link seems to have been removed since trawl.
Sun - 1 link http://www.bretton.ac.uk/
"University College Bretton Hall"
Link to http://java.sun.com/
SGI - 1 link http://www.sghms.ac.uk/
"St. George's Hospital Medical School"
Link to http://www.sgi.com/ and "Powered by Silicon Graphics" commentary
Macromedia - 1 link
(http://www.macromedia.com/Tools/Shockwave/)
http://www.bretton.ac.uk/
"University College Bretton Hall"
A link to the Shockwave plugin
Browserwatch - 1 link
(http://www.browserwatch.com/)
http://www.bathhe.ac.uk/
"Bath Spa University College"
A help page about browsers and browser plugins
U-NET - 1 link
(http://www.u-net.net/services/janet/)
http://www.qmced.ac.uk/
"Queen Mary College Edinburgh"
Link in menu item: "Internet and JANET Access"
Demon - 1 link
http://www.demon.net/inews/search.html
http://www.umds.ac.uk/
"United Medical and Dental Schools of Guy's and St Thomas's Hospitals"
Link in menu item: "Major Web Listings and Search Engines"

Table 4 - Links To Other Computer Organisations From Institutional Home Pages
Service and Nos. of Links Linked from Comment
counter.digits.com - 2 links http://www.ucscarb.ac.uk/
"University College Scarborough"
A page counter
http://www.scot.ac.uk/
"Scottish College of Textiles"
A page counter, together with a link to the page counter home page
Recreational Software Advisory Council on the Internet
(http://www.rsac.org/) - 2 links
http://www.ehche.ac.uk/
"Edge Hill College"
An RSAC icon
http://www.luton.ac.uk/
"University of Luton"
An RSAC icon
Apache (http://www.apache.org/) - 2 links http://www.lsu.soton.ac.uk/
"LSU College of Higher Education"
A "Powered by Apache" icon and link
http://www.rfhsm.ac.uk/
"Royal Free Hospital School of Medicine"
A "Powered by Apache" icon and link
Electronic Frontier Foundation
(http://www.eff.org/) - 1 link
http://www.uwcm.ac.uk/
"University of Wales College of Medicine"
A "Support Freedom of Speech on the Internet" icon and link
Vocal Computers (http://www.vocal.co.uk/) - 1 link http://www.buckscol.ac.uk/
"Buckinghamshire University College"
A "Copyright Vocal Computers Ltd. 1997" statement and link.

Table 5 - Links To Non-Computer Organisations From Institutional Home Pages
Resource and Nos. of Links Linked from Comment
Hertsfordshire Visual Arts Forum
(http://www.hvaf.org.uk/) - 1 link
http://www.herts.ac.uk/
"University Of Hertfordshire"
Link in menu to list of local organisations
http://www.open.gov.uk/welwyn/whhome.htm http://www.herts.ac.uk/
"University Of Hertfordshire"
Link in menu to list of local organisations
http://www.stalbans.gov.uk/ http://www.herts.ac.uk/
"University Of Hertfordshire"
Link in menu to list of local organisations
http://www.herts.co.uk/ http://www.herts.ac.uk/
"University Of Hertfordshire"
Link in menu to list of local organisations
http://www.terrapin.co.uk/watford/ http://www.herts.ac.uk/
"University Of Hertfordshire"
Link in menu to list of local organisations
http://www.hants.gov.uk/ http://www.solent.ac.uk/
"Southampton Institute"
Link to community information
http://birmingham.gov.uk/ - 2 links http://www.westhill.ac.uk/
"Westhill College of Higher Education"
Link to menu item about Birmingham
http://www.bham.ac.uk/
"University Of Birmingham"
Icon and link to information about "The City and Region"
http://www.tcol.co.uk/orgs/harper/harper.htm - 1 link http://sun1.haac.ac.uk/
"Harper Adams Agricultural College"
Link to the corresponding Commonwealth Website
http://recruitnet.guardian.co.uk/ - 1 link http://www.unl.ac.uk/welcome.html
"University of North London"
Form to Guardian jobs page for jbs at UNL
http://host1.kbnet.co.uk/rleggat/westminster/ - 1 link http://www.ox-west.ac.uk/
"Westminster College Oxford"
http://www.netins.net/showcase/umsource/ - 1 link http://www.ox-west.ac.uk/
"Westminster College Oxford"
http://on-tyne.north-east.co.uk/ - 1 link http://www.ncl.ac.uk/
"University of Newcastle upon Tyne"
Link to information about the city
http://www.broadnet.co.uk/ - 1 link http://www.wlv.ac.uk/
"University of Wolverhampton"
Link to "a major University of Wolverhampton R&D project"
http://ds.dial.pipex.com/ciem/ - 1 link http://www.chihe.ac.uk/
"Chichester Institute of Higher Education"
Icon and link to "The Centre for International Education and Management"
http://www.covuni.demon.co.uk/ - 1 link http://www.coventry.ac.uk/
"Coventry University"
Link to the International Office
http://www.tcp.co.uk/~lsu/ - 1 link http://www.lsu.soton.ac.uk/
"LSU College of Higher Education"
A menu link to "Historical & Political Studies"

Total Numbers of Links on Institutional Home Pages

Figure 1 gives a histogram showing the number of links from institutional home pages.

Histogram of Numbers of Links versus Frequency
Figure 1 - Histogram of Numbers of Links versus Frequency

As can be see from Figure 1, the mean value for numbers of links is 17, with the median being in the range 10-15 links.

Commentary

The analysis shows that there are only a small number of links to JISC services from UK University and Colleges home pages. However this should not be surprising, as most institution home pages provide only small numbers of links.

There were rather more links to computing companies, in particular to Netscape and Microsoft.

Eight institutions provided links to information about the local area hosted by commercial or goivernment services.

Recommendations

The following recommendations are made:

  1. The survey of UK Universities and Colleges institutional home pages should be carried out on a regular basis.
  2. Feedback on this initial survey should be sought from JISC services and institutional webmasters.
  3. WebWatch surveys should be carried out across institutional web sites in order to monitor links to JISC services and linking profiles to remote services.

Survey Limitations

Note that the WebWatch robot software currently does not follow Web pages which make use of <FRAMES> or which use the <META> HTTP-EQUIV="refresh" attribute which provide redirection to other pages.

References

  1. HE Universities and Colleges,
    See <URL:http://www.hesa.ac.uk/hesect/he_inst.htm>
  2. WebWatching UK Universities and Colleges, Ariadne Issue 12
    See <URL: http://www.ariadne.ac.uk/issue12/web-focus/>
  3. JISC Services,
    See <URL: http://www.jisc.ac.uk/services/>